2002 Uniform Regional Scab Nursery for Spring Wheat Parents
Coordinator: David F. Garvin
USDA-ARS, Plant Science Research Unit
411 Borlaug Hall, University of Minnesota
1991 Upper Buford Circle, St. Paul, MN 55108
Report prepared by: David F. Garvin and Leanne
Matthiesen
The Uniform Regional Scab Nursery was grown for the eighth
year in 2002. Six locations were included in the nursery,
including Brookings, SD; St. Paul and Crookston, MN; Prosper and
Langdon, ND; and Glenlea, MB, Canada. Data were obtained from
all locations for inclusion in this report. A total of 44
entries were included in the nursery in 2002. This included the
resistant checks 2375, BacUp, and ND2710, and the susceptible
checks Wheaton and Oslo. The other 39 entries were contributed
by the University of Minnesota, North Dakota State University,
South Dakota State University, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada,
Western Plant Breeders, and Agripro. Seven of these 39 entries
were durums. Five genotypes from South Dakota (PI entries)
represent possible new sources of scab resistance and were
included in the nursery.
The field data collected at each location varied, but a core
set of traits evaluated on entries at 5 locations or more
included incidence of scab (expressed as % infected heads),
disease severity (expressed as % of diseased florets on infected
heads), disease index (incidence x severity/100), and visual
scabby kernel ratings (VSK, tombstone), expressed as % kernels
in a grain sample. Additionally, 4 locations provided grain
deoxynivalenol (DON) concentrations, expressed as ppm in a grain
sample. Other trait data were gathered at the different
locations, and are presented in the individual location tables.
A final table reporting overall entry means for parameters across
locations is included after individual location data tables.
Further, relative rankings of entries for disease incidence,
disease severity, disease index, VSK and DON are provided as new
tables in this year's report.
Disease pressure varied from location to location, with mean
disease incidence ranging from a low of 52.3% for Langdon to a
high of 99.8% at Brookings. Mean location severities ranged from
7.7% at Langdon to 67.4% at Prosper, while mean disease index
ranged from 4.8% at Langdon to 46.9% at Brookings. Mean VSK
ranged from 8% at Crookston to 46.5% at Prosper. It should be
noted that the nursery locations in Minnesota do not record VSK
ratings if they exceed 50%, and thus the VSK means at these
locations will be biased towards values lower than the true
means. Mean location DON concentrations ranged from 3.5 ppm at
Crookston to 36.9 ppm at Prosper.
Correlation coefficients were calculated between disease
index, VSK, and DON, using overall means calculated from the
locations at which each of these parameters was measured. The
correlations among these parameters were in each instance
positive and significant. The correlation between disease index
and VSK (4 locations) was 0.91, while disease index and DON (3
locations) exhibited a correlation of 0.85. Lastly, VSK and DON
(3 locations) also exhibited a significant correlation (0.77).